University chapels are often overlooked as vital sites for congregational worship and music. This attitude is reinforced when pastors, professors, or parents warn their students that “church is not the same as chapel.” While I agree that college students and faculty should still, as much as possible, pursue Christian fellowship in local church congregations, I worry that these claims can too easily dismiss the realities of worship outside traditional understandings of “church.” The idea that chapel is more temporary, transient, or detached compared to the neighboring church can unintentionally insinuate a comparative sense of inferiority.
Recent research has opened greater visibility and legitimacy to expressions of worship outside of conventional parish settings. In an ever-changing religious landscape, Christians are finding new ways in which God invites them to worship. Ethnomusicologist Monique Ingalls calls these “modes of congregating.”
College and university chapels are one of these “modes of congregating”—distinct expressions of congregational life, the body of Christ called and assembled by the Spirit in a particular context. Rather than dismissing chapels as simply “not church” and therefore unworthy of further consideration, this identification enables us to explore what it means when students and faculty sing together on a college campus.
Chapel as Laboratory
A common metaphor for the university chapel is that of a laboratory: a place of innovating and trying unconventional ideas. Introducing less familiar songs and musical styles often faces less resistance here, thanks to higher congregational turnover (i.e., student graduation and faculty/staff transitions) and thus less commitment to a song diet. In seminaries (and perhaps Bible colleges), the metaphor can also convey a sense of trial and error as future church musicians use the chapel as a venue for vocational preparation.
The laboratory image fits well in an undergraduate chapel—especially within Christian liberal arts or comprehensive universities, which foster integration across disciplines as part of engaging Christ’s redemptive mission. It reminds us that worshiping in chapel is exploratory. Part of what makes chapel unique is its unsettled, often eccentric, gathering brought together each season by the ordinary mechanisms of enrollment, wherein, whether realizing it or not, God’s hand guides students from diverse disciplines and walks of life to pursue Truth as one people.
The transience and turnover of a chapel can be viewed as a liability, compared with the relatively long-term stability of a typical parish, but what if this quality opens avenues to explore new forms of faithfulness to that community at that time?
We should not assume that the relative stability of a parish necessarily means that chapel worship is less significant. Yet regrettably, when it becomes erratic improvisation or unserious planning, the laboratory image can damage how we perceive chapel worship.
The problem with the laboratory image is that it can suggest rogue experimentation: exploration without expectations. It can turn chapel planning into a free-for-all, where anything goes. We begin to turn the chapel congregant into what we dread in higher education: Students as paying customers for the educational experience, now including worship.
Rogue experimentation is a symptom of neglecting the chapel’s congregational identity in favor of other priorities. It is challenging to steward a chapel congregation’s song if you are only relying on the shifting song trends of today—for example, only singing from the CCLI Top 100 in a well-meaning effort to be relevant. And it is just as challenging if you enforce an unchanging repertoire of “what worked” with previous groups of students, an equally well-intentioned effort to honor a school’s heritage.
Even for colleges affiliated with a particular denomination, situated within a particular confessional tradition, or experiencing a critical mass of students from a particular ecclesial background, there will always be a song that feels “new” to someone, perhaps more so than in a church that has had time to establish a more fixed repertoire. Struggling with this reality has led to some misguided approaches to selecting songs for this distinct “mode of congregating.”
Instead, much like a science lab, faithful experimentation requires clear intentionality and expectations. These are shepherded by pastoral musicians, student interns, campus chaplains, and administrative committees—leaders entrusted by God to care for this unique congregation.
Strategies for Singing Together in Chapel

Some chapel worship models are akin to a progressive dinner—taking turns inviting others inside and consuming cultural styles. Each service is a new “stop” to sample another worship style before moving to the next home. While it can be appealing (and pragmatic) to have separate song services to get a taste for different communities—one service only with American contemporary worship songs, another with organ-led psalmody, another with Taizé chants, another with Latin American praise music—these detached, rotating services can be pastorally problematic.
This strategy can arise from good intentions to devote entire services to underrepresented cultural expressions of worship. While this hospitality is important, it can create liturgical whiplash, leaving little unity or continuity across a semester-long range of services. Further, some research on Christian colleges has raised concerns that culturally separated services can reinforce existing ethnic divisions on a predominantly monoethnic campus. They can expose students to diversity without necessarily expecting any real participation alongside those songs. They only ask students to move to the next stop, instead of incorporating others’ sung prayers into a shared repertoire.
Instead, our faithful experimentation should seek a convergence toward what Constance Cherry calls a congregation’s worship voice, rather than isolated song services that feel like disconnected side dishes supporting a dominant culture’s main entrée. We should resist a “playlist shuffling” approach to song selection, where we try out new songs for new communities each week without long-term structural stewardship and balance. Likewise, we should avoid starting from scratch each year, throwing away last year’s songs deemed no longer relevant, as if there is no needed continuity between academic terms.
These approaches do not dignify the short- and long-range diversity of the chapel congregation; they flatten chapel as a sterile vacuum for unbounded or uncritical decision-making. Rather than embracing the Spirit-breathed identity that God has already given to this congregation—and discerning songs that can express and form this identity—we avoid shepherding the chapel with careful song selection and programming. It is easier to categorize chapel worship as another weekly on-campus student affairs program, and not much more than that.
When we overlook the chapel as a congregation of its own kind, we can compromise on our decision-making process, molding the student body along our own preferences, visions, and institutional aspirations rather than honoring the community that the Spirit has already gathered.
This kind of shepherding is the harder choice, because it requires that we overcome the front-of-mind excuses we tell ourselves:
- It’s too overwhelming, so why even try to begin?
- It’s not what we’re used to, so why rock the boat?
- It’s not going to last after they graduate, so why put in the effort?
The university chapel has a wonderful opportunity to pursue ecumenical and intercultural worship in ways that are less common among local churches. This is one of many blessings that God brings to this expression of congregational life, but it also calls for wisdom.
Where to Start
Overcoming these temptations requires a pastoral posture as we learn to listen to the people whom God has assembled on our campuses.
- Listen to the chapel songs that your students have sung in the past.
Audit your existing repertoire, whether by reviewing a Planning Center report, an archive of bulletins, or even a list made to the best recollection. Which songs have become constitutive of your chapel congregation’s worship voice, even if they are unfamiliar to your current students, and can be an important way of maintaining a sense of congregational identity? Next, ask the harder question: Which songs have become old wineskins—able to hold our praise for a season, but no longer fitting for the current community God has gathered?
But be critical to avoid evaluating based on preference or taste alone: Why are those songs kept, and others retired?
- Is the theological content aligned with the institutional ethos?
- Do the song’s musical qualities—especially its range and rhythms—enable active participation?
- Has the song been embodied in congregational life in special ways, such as to mark a ceremony or occasion particular to the academic life?
- Listen to the songs that your students in chapel today are singing.
In the university chapel, God brings together students and faculty who carry songs from the many places they call home. They can offer these songs as gifts to your campus, their shared home for a season. Instead of assuming that “all students from this background or tradition sing this song,” invite your students to tell you what songs are meaningful from the congregations that nurtured them. You can draw these concerns out through committee or planning meetings, individual pastoral conversations, or brief forms posted on social media.
To avoid seeming like you are promising “song requests,” be mindful also to ask why those particular songs are spiritually significant.
- Was the song used during special occasions?
- Do you have a memory associated with singing this song?
- What has the song taught you about who God is to you and your home congregation?
- Listen together so the chapel can be a place where students can sing in one voice.
God uses a distinct, contextual catalog of songs to shape each worshiping community into our Christian identity. The chapel is a place to sing with its “saints”—in this case, students of the past who have been part of this congregation—and with its current community. Instead of planning songs “on shuffle” or as compartmentalized “food samples,” shepherd a short- and long-range song diet that allows these songs to harmonize with your chapel’s unique worship voice. And as pastoral musicians, we must look beyond mere song selection and consider the liturgical function of our congregational music—attending to how we introduce, frame, and lead songs to honor their communities.
Chapel, like all congregations, is a place where we creatively work out—and sing out—our identity as God’s people. Our musical decisions are a crucial part of that exploration. Thus, we must experiment faithfully in our liturgical laboratory—not treating the chapel congregation as a blank slate, or as a shrunken-down version of church undeserving of deeper reflection. Instead, trusting that the Spirit has already shaped us into a community, our faithful experimentation ought to help us sing together as Christ’s body.
The seasons change faster in a university worship setting than in a traditional parish; this should call us to be attentive to the Spirit’s unpredictable work as God brings additional classes into our chapels each fall. What an exciting, humbling challenge! Ultimately, it calls those responsible for stewarding the sung prayers of a chapel to stay on our toes in curiosity, and on our knees in prayer.
May the Spirit help us fill our campus chapels with praise, so that students from generation to generation—or better yet, from graduation to graduation—might sing to one another.
Rev. Benjamin P. Snoek (PhD, Columbia International University) is an ordained minister in the Reformed Church in America. He previously served as a chaplain at Trinity Christian College and Asbury University. He explores some of this article’s ideas further in his first book, Worship in University Chapels: Christian Colleges and Liturgical Formation (De Gruyter Brill, 2026).
